Movie Review: Edge of Darkness

It's been eight years since we've seen Mel Gibson on the silver screen. In that time he's been busy. He made controversy, and money, with his personal Sistine Chapel, "The Passion of the Christ." He confirmed peoples' worst suspicions with a drunken anti-Semitic rant while being arrested for DUI. He vehemently defended his conservative brand of Catholicism, only to father a love child with a Russian singer and leave his wife and seven children.

Know what? This would make a good movie.

Unfortunately for him, the vehicle he chose as a comeback, "Edge of Darkness," opening Friday January 29, isn't nearly as interesting as his personal life.

Gibson plays a tough Boston cop with a beloved daughter, Emma (played by the extravagantly named Bojana Novakovic). She's graduated from MIT and landed a job at a high security firm. She arrives on his doorstep violently ill and clearly troubled. Before she can unburden her soul to him, wouldn't you know it, someone kills her.

Gibson's Tom Craven sets out to find who killed his little girl, leaving a trail of mangled bodies behind him. His investigation leads him to a conspiracy that penetrates the very halls of power in DC.

I didn't much care for this film because it made me feel old.

Let me explain.

I was sitting by myself, but had my wonderful husband been with me, I would have been pestering him with grandma-like questions. "Who's that guy?" "What's he mean?" "Why'd he do that?" and "What happened to that other guy?"

I'm too young to be a grandma. Hollywood, please make films that make sense.

The plot jumped around like a washing machine with a bowling ball inside. Plot threads were abandoned, never to be seen again. Characters came and went without much explanation. The washing machine just kept spinning.

The producers, for reasons that I'm sure seemed logical at the time, hired three similar actors to play three bad guys. Or at least I think that's what happened. I was never sure who was on screen. Note to my readers: The Senator is the dude with the big ears. I think.

I never really quite got the gist of the conspiracy, either. Maybe I need someone to explain it to me. Loudly. With charts.

Maybe that all doesn't matter so much. Gibson, for his part, revived his tough-guy-on-the-brink role. No one does it quite like our Mel. His character's heart was breaking and the only way he could find to express his feelings was by fist or bullet. On screen, at least, Gibson's tough guy never strays from due north on the moral compass.

There's a reason why Mel Gibson spent two decades on the top of Hollywood's A-list. He's still gripping after all these years.

He's still violent too. If you like the splatter of a good head shot or the shock of a sudden body slam with a car, this is the film for you. It's quick and intense and has its satisfying moments.

Just send me a note explaining what happened when you get home, would ya?

Watch the Edge of Darkness trailer here.

Rebecca Cusey

Rebecca Cusey is the official movie reviewer for SixSeeds.tv. A member of the Washington DC Area Film Critics Association and the Television Critics Association, she does celebrity interviews, reviews, trend pieces, and event coverage. Her work has appeared in USA Today, Comcast.net, World Magazine, National Review Online, Relevant Magazine, Beliefnet.com, Crosswalk.com, numerous newspapers, and many other outlets.
Bookmark and Share Read more in: Movies > Content

Comments

by Nancy French #

on Wednesday, Jan 27th 2010 @ 21:04pm
Rebecca, I watched "39 Steps" -- Alfred Hitchcock's 1939 classic. I don't think that flick was the first to feature a person dying right before she's able to tell the important info to the main protagonist... but... It is amazing to see how many films use that set up.

Great review!

by Jean Yih Kingston #

on Friday, Jan 29th 2010 @ 7:02am
Maybe it says something about myself, but I find there are times I don't care when I don't understand the plot perfectly (or the plot is too confusing to truly understand). Guess I sometimes do use movies purely for the "ride" it takes me on!

by Gary Katz #

on Friday, Jan 29th 2010 @ 10:30am
I greatly appreciate your opening paragraph setting the context a review of the movie by noting the hypocracy and amorality of Gibson's personal life. In general, I don't think its helpful to focus on an actor's personal views when reviewing their professional work. But when someone like Gibson loudly and publicy uses their fame and forturne--and their professional work (Passion)-- in an attempt to promote their religious and ethical outlook, the confluence (or lack thereof) of personal and professional becomes relevant indeed. Thanks for the thoughtful review.

by Tim #

on Friday, Jan 29th 2010 @ 11:57am
Im not sure who is more duluded. Katz or the "critic" above.

by Rebecca Cusey #

on Saturday, Jan 30th 2010 @ 12:18pm
Gary, thanks for the props. I'm still rooting for Mel. I'd love to see him make more art. I'd love to see him reconcile his faith and his life. I think we're all in the same boat at some point, not living up to our own standards. Mel just paints it with a bigger brush and more scruitny than the rest of us. I believe grace is bigger still.

by Rebecca Cusey #

on Saturday, Jan 30th 2010 @ 12:22pm
Nancy, I'll have to check that one out. Sounds good.

by Rebecca Cusey #

on Saturday, Jan 30th 2010 @ 12:22pm
Jean: I agree. The ride is the thing. The reason we go to the movies.

by Bill Comer #

on Sunday, Jan 31st 2010 @ 20:11pm
Thanks, Rebecca. I'm new to SixSeeds and familiar with many of its voices, but not yours. I love this review. And while it's unlikely I'll see the movie (the entertainment budget as it connects to movies is pretty much dedicated to "G" fair as I usually have a three year old in tow), your lead paragraph spoke my own heart when it turns to Mel Gibson. I've seen "The Passion of Christ" at least five times, with each viewing taking me deeper into the mystery that is Jesus. Gibson's gift on this front is, in my estimation, inestimable. On the other hand, his politics and personal failings (like my own), put me in a place of conflict. Your kindness and hopefulness, both in the review and in the follow-up, brings with it a "true north" perspective, one my personal compass loses when pointed in certain directions. So, thanks. This was quite helpful. I look forward to seeing more of your work.

Bill

by Rebecca Cusey #

on Monday, Feb 01st 2010 @ 10:27am
Bill, thank you so much for your kind note. It was really very encouraging.

And, please, if you've got limited time and money for entertainment, my recommendation as a trained, certified, and card-carrying professional movie critic is to skip Edge of Darkness but make sure you catch Avatar before it leaves theaters.

Post Your Comment

Got something to say? Join the conversation by adding your comment below. Name and comment are required.

name@host.com
http://your-website.com


Please, no HTML or other tags in the comments